Wednesday, October 30, 2024

On Politics: Bearing the weight of democracy

Election workers are trying to pull off an election and restore faith in a system under attack.
On Politics

October 30, 2024

A window on door bears the words
The office of the Irwin County Board of Elections and Registrations in Ocilla, Ga., on Saturday. Jess Bidgood/The New York Times

LETTER FROM OCILLA

When the weight of democracy is on your shoulders

The latest, with 6 days to go

For Ethan Compton, the election supervisor in Irwin County, Ga., the last few years have brought a series of man-made and natural hazards.

Real hurricanes. A hailstorm of open-records requests. Conspiracy theories that settle in like summertime humidity. A crush of new laws and regulations often backed by the drivers of those conspiracy theories, and the thrumming distrust of some of the voters he serves.

And then, to top it all off, there was the Sweet Potato Festival Parade.

Last weekend, I drove to Ocilla, a town of about 3,000 surrounded by rich farmland that serves as the county seat. I was hoping for a glimpse of what it's like to run an election in 2024. When I arrived, I found Compton speaking animatedly to a law enforcement officer who had, in advance of the parade, just closed the block in front of the building where early voting was to take place.

Compton had asked the officer if he would show drivers a detour to his building. "At first, he had said, 'Oh no, that's not my job,'" said Compton, who worried that voters might not know how to get into his building . "I was like, 'OK, I'm going to have to drop the D.O.J. on them.'"

The officer quickly changed his mind. The crisis was averted. It was a small thing — a one-block detour for a celebration of a root vegetable. But to Compton, who is trying not just to pull off an election but also to restore voters' overall faith in the system he runs, everything matters.

"It has been a steady effort," he told me, "of trying to build trust again in elections since 2020."

One stressor after another

Compton is 35, with a full beard and a soft but exacting lilt. He never really planned on becoming an elections official. He had spent his career repairing computers, and doing quality assurance testing on surgical instruments — a line of work that taught him, he said, "that even the smallest mistakes could endanger people."

After he moved to rural south Georgia from East Tennessee, he got a job in early 2020 as a technician working on Dominion voting machines, which led him to Irwin County. He began working for the county elections department the following year. He's not really sure what it's like to administer an election in a time without election denialism and disinformation, because he never has.

Instead, it's been one stressor after another. A hand recount in December 2020 caused an officewide Covid outbreak. After then-President Donald Trump and his allies began spreading false claims about election fraud in Georgia, turnout in the January 2021 runoff election plummeted, and Compton worried voters' trust was fast eroding — even in a county like this, where Trump had won 75 percent of the vote. The next day was Jan. 6, 2021, and the local sheriff pre-emptively stationed a deputy across from Compton's house.

Compton hasn't faced the same tide of harassment and threats as others in his profession, though he doesn't feel quite safe, either. When the elections board moved to its current location, across the street from what used to be the grocery store, it added layers of alarms, thickened the walls, and considered adding bulletproof glass.

"Seeing the comments, the vitriol online, it has made me have to look over my shoulder a lot more," he said.

There are also the sarcastic comments, like when voters cast their ballot but suggest it won't count. The voters who wanted him to spend hours addressing all of their concerns — which he did. There was the flurry of open-records requests, pushed by right-wing activists in spring 2022 — "I had more open records requests about the results than I had voters," Compton said — and the time a group of activists showed up during a special election in 2023, demanding to take pictures inside while voting was occurring.

"They act like they know the law in order to intimidate people that do not understand it fully," Compton said. "So you have to be well-versed on thousands of pages of law as well as public relations, auditing, cybersecurity."

Compton said he was constantly thinking about how to be transparent and how to stop conspiracy theories from taking root. Sometimes it feels like the conspiracy theorists are winning. Distrust keeps people away from the ballot box — and he takes that personally.

"It's silencing people's votes," he said. "If people aren't taking part, then I'm not doing enough of a good job."

On permanent alert

Compton thinks he's making progress on rebuilding voters' faith. More than 2,650 early votes have already been cast in person — impressive turnout for a county with only 6,600 registered voters.

When I visited on Saturday, voters trickled into a windowless room that the assistant supervisor, Evelyn Romans, had livened up with shockingly healthy potted plants decorated with patriotic gnomes. In the corner of the room stood a dropbox.

Every hour, one poll worker cross-checked the number of voters against the number of ballots made and cast — essentially doing an audit in real time. Compton seemed on permanent alert, watching for people who might need help — or who might inadvertently be breaking a rule. He told a man that his "Raised by Reagan" T-shirt was too political to wear into the voting booth, and somberly explained to an elderly woman that she would not be allowed to vote because she hadn't brought a photo ID.

In some ways, it was hard to imagine distrust flourishing in a close-knit place like this, where some of the poll workers recognized voters, and people chatted idly about hurricane cleanup or the Sweet Potato Festival. But it does. Lately, the big concern has been the baseless rumor that machines are switching people's votes.

Compton feels sure that time and communication are the antidotes to disinformation. What he does not know, though, is what the November election and its aftermath will bring to his community.

"Do I have to start all over again on the four-year cycle?" he wondered. "Or is this a step forward?"

Related reads:

2024

One Story You Shouldn't Miss

People are seated in the observation gallery of the Arizona State House of Representatives.
The chambers of the Arizona House. Both the House and Senate are up for grabs in the elections this year. Ash Ponders for The New York Times

The down-ballot battles with big policy implications

Arizona. Michigan. Pennsylvania. No, I'm not talking about swing states. I'm talking about states where the two parties are battling for control of state legislatures. The nation's statehouses play a huge role in shaping policy, so these races really matter. My colleague David Chen has this guide to the four kinds of battles we'll see next Tuesday.

1. States where Republicans hold both chambers

In Arizona, Republicans hold a 16-14 edge in the Senate, and 32-28 in the House, and both chambers are seen as tossups. Democrats are highlighting public education, housing affordability and, above all, abortion rights — which is also the subject of a ballot measure. Republicans are emphasizing the economy, the border and immigration — another hot-button initiative.

In New Hampshire, Republicans have clung to a slim state government trifecta — control of the governor's office and both legislative chambers — for the last four years. But this year, against the backdrop of a highly competitive governor's race, Democrats are bullish about their chances to reclaim the House, which, with 400 members, is the largest state legislative body in the country.

2. States where Democrats want to protect new trifectas

Democrats narrowly won trifectas in four states after the 2022 midterms, and parlayed that power into laws related to abortion, labor, voting rights and more. Now their House majorities in two of those states are rated as too close to call: Michigan and Minnesota.

The Michigan House was deadlocked at 54-54 this year after a couple of Democratic representatives resigned to serve as mayors. Legislation basically ground to a halt until Democrats regained their advantage in April.

In Minnesota, Democrats have a 68-64 edge in the House, with two vacancies, after shepherding a sweeping agenda that helped make Gov. Tim Walz a progressive star. A special Senate election will determine the balance of power in that chamber, which is tied.

3. The state with a divided Legislature

In 2022, Democrats in Pennsylvania captured the state House of Representatives, winning some races by just a few hundred votes, after more than a decade out of power. They've prevailed in five special elections since to preserve their one-vote majority.

If Republicans can regain power in the House — and retain the Senate — they hope to restrict abortion access and tighten voter ID requirements, among other policy goals.

4. The state where new maps could shift control

Pennsylvania Democrats benefited from redrawn district lines in 2022. After the state Supreme Court threw out Wisconsin's gerrymandered legislative maps, Democrats now have an opportunity to win the Assembly for the first time in more than a decade.

David W. Chen

MORE POLITICS NEWS AND ANALYSIS

Former President Donald J. Trump standing onstage with several men, two of whom are wearing white caps.

Kenny Holston/The New York Times

News Analysis

What Muslim Ban? Trump Tries to Sidestep Years of Islamophobia.

Former President Donald J. Trump is trying to persuade a potentially decisive group of Arab and Muslim voters that they should vote for him, even though he has spent years insulting and demonizing them.

By Hamed Aleaziz

Kamala Harris, wearing a dark suit, stands at a lectern with a large American flag behind her.

Erin Schaff/The New York Times

Does Kamala Harris Back Free Health Care for Illegal Immigrants?

Donald Trump and other Republicans have said repeatedly that she does. Her history on the issue is complicated.

By Emily Baumgaertner and Margot Sanger-Katz

Article Image

Erin Schaff/The New York Times

the ad campaign

A Farm-Raised Steelworker Speaks Up for Harris and Against Trump (and Elon Musk)

Carhartt, a western Pennsylvania accent and a backdrop of tools provide blue-collar credibility in a new ad from Future Forward, the main super PAC aiding Kamala Harris.

By Katie Glueck

Robert F. Kennedy Jr. gesturing at a lectern.

Kenny Holston/The New York Times

R.F.K. Jr. Said Trump Promised Him Control of Public Health Agencies. The Campaign Called That Premature.

The onetime independent presidential candidate, who dropped out and is backing Donald J. Trump, has in recent years promoted unproven theories about the dangers of pharmaceutical treatments.

By Rebecca Davis O'Brien

Senator Mitch McConnell of Kentucky, left, and The Times's Carl Hulse wearing suits, talking in a hallway at the Capitol.

Kent Nishimura

times insider

Twenty Election Cycles and Counting

Carl Hulse has covered congressional campaigns for four decades. Much has changed, but one thing remains constant: Journalists must be ready for the unexpected.

By Carl Hulse

Article Image

Photo Illustration by Mark Harris

Elon Musk Wants Big Families. He Bought a Secret Compound for His.

As the billionaire warns of population collapse and the moral obligation to have children, he's navigating his own complicated family.

By Kirsten Grind, Ryan Mac and Sheera Frenkel

Read past editions of the newsletter here.

If you're enjoying what you're reading, please consider recommending it to others. They can sign up here.

Have feedback? Ideas for coverage? We'd love to hear from you. Email us at onpolitics@nytimes.com.

You'll receive Nate Cohn's analysis of the latest election data and notifications when a new Times/Siena poll is released.

Try four weeks of complimentary access to The Tilt

Nate Cohn, The Times's chief political analyst, makes sense of the latest political data.

Get it in your inbox
A square filled with smaller squares and rectangles in shades of red and blue. The numbers

Need help? Review our newsletter help page or contact us for assistance.

You received this email because you signed up for On Politics from The New York Times.

To stop receiving On Politics, unsubscribe. To opt out of other promotional emails from The Times, including those regarding The Athletic, manage your email settings. To opt out of updates and offers sent from The Athletic, submit a request.

Subscribe to The Times

Connect with us on:

facebookxinstagramwhatsapp

Change Your EmailPrivacy PolicyContact UsCalifornia Notices

LiveIntent LogoAdChoices Logo

The New York Times Company. 620 Eighth Avenue New York, NY 10018

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home